Florida HOA Rights — Common Elements vs Limited Common Elements

The Three Categories That Determine Who Pays for What

Every square inch of a Florida condominium falls into one of three categories. Which category determines who is responsible for maintenance and repair — and who pays.

Florida Statute § 718.103 · § 718.113

Florida law defines three distinct ownership and responsibility categories in every condominium.

Florida Statute § 718.103 defines units, common elements, and limited common elements. Florida § 718.113 determines who is responsible for maintaining each. The specific boundaries in your community are defined by your Declaration of Condominium — which controls over any general rule. When in doubt, your Declaration is the governing document.

Read Florida Statute § 718.113 →

🏠

Unit — Owner's Responsibility

Interior walls, floors, ceilings (inside the unit)
Interior fixtures — lights, cabinets, appliances
Interior plumbing and electrical within the unit
Interior doors and interior window coverings
Everything from the paint inward in most buildings
Owner maintains and pays at their own cost

🏗️

Limited Common Element — Complicated

Balconies, patios, porches assigned to a specific unit
Parking spaces assigned to a specific unit
Storage units assigned to a specific unit
Some HVAC equipment serving only one unit
Part of common elements — but for exclusive use of one owner
Association usually maintains — owner often pays

🏢

Common Element — Association's Responsibility

Roof, exterior walls, structural components
Lobbies, hallways, elevators, stairwells
Swimming pool, fitness center, clubhouse
Shared plumbing and electrical systems
Windows and exterior doors (in most buildings)
Association maintains and pays — all owners share cost

Real Scenarios — Who Pays?

Scenario: Water is leaking from my upstairs neighbor's unit through my ceiling.

Depends — read your Declaration

If the leak is from a common plumbing line — association responsibility. If it's from the unit above (a broken toilet, washing machine, or unpermitted plumbing work) — the unit owner above may be liable. Florida courts have found both associations and unit owners responsible depending on the source of the leak and the specific declaration language. Document everything and notify both the board and the upstairs owner in writing immediately.

Scenario: My balcony railing is corroded and unsafe. Who fixes it?

Usually Association

Balconies are typically limited common elements — for your exclusive use, but part of the building's structure. Florida § 718.113 generally makes the association responsible for maintaining limited common elements, though your Declaration may shift some costs to the owner. The structural components of a balcony — including railings — are almost always association responsibility, especially after the post-Surfside legislation.

Scenario: My window frame is rotting. The HOA says it's my problem. Is that right?

Depends on your Declaration

Windows are one of the most contested items in Florida condo law. In many buildings, windows are common elements maintained by the association. In others, they are unit owner responsibility. The key is your Declaration — look for how it defines the unit boundary and what it says specifically about windows. If the Declaration is silent or ambiguous, Florida § 718.113 generally defaults to association responsibility for exterior elements.

Scenario: The pipe inside my wall burst. Who pays?

Depends on which pipe and what it serves

In Florida condos, pipes that serve only one unit and are within the unit boundaries are typically the owner's responsibility. Pipes that serve multiple units or are within common walls are typically association responsibility. The distinction is often whether the pipe is a "branch" line serving only your unit versus a main line serving the building. Your Declaration and a licensed plumber's assessment are both essential in pipe disputes.

Scenario: The association says they'll fix the common element that damaged my unit — but won't pay for my interior damage.

Association may owe for consequential damages

Florida courts have found that when an association's failure to maintain a common element causes damage to a unit, the association may be liable for the resulting damage to the unit interior — not just the common element itself. Document all damage thoroughly with photos and written descriptions, notify the board in writing, and consult a Florida HOA attorney if the association refuses to address consequential damage.

What To Do When You Disagree About Responsibility

📝

For Residents

Pull out your Declaration and find the unit boundary definition
Find what it says specifically about the item in dispute
Submit your maintenance request in writing — email creates a record
If the board denies responsibility, ask them to cite the specific Declaration provision
Document all damage with dated photos
If dispute is significant — consult a Florida HOA attorney

📋

For Boards

Have a written maintenance responsibility chart based on your specific Declaration
Respond to all maintenance requests in writing with the Declaration basis for your decision
Never verbally deny responsibility — put it in writing with the legal basis
For ambiguous situations — consult association counsel before denying responsibility
Remember: association failure to maintain can create liability for owner damages

The single most important thing to know: Your Declaration of Condominium controls. General rules about what is common element versus unit are starting points — your specific Declaration may define things differently. Always go to your Declaration first, and bring it with you when you consult an attorney.

This is general legal information, not legal advice. Common element versus limited common element disputes are among the most litigated issues in Florida condominium law. For disputes involving significant repair costs, consult a Florida HOA attorney and bring your Declaration.